Financial Health Programs Are Not Working. Here Is What Replaces Them.

bc blog feature financial health

Every community bank and credit union says it cares about the financial health of its account holders. Most of them mean it. Very few can prove it.

The data backs that up. In a recent Cornerstone Advisors survey, only 53% of consumers who consider a credit union their primary institution said it was helping improve their financial health and performance. Primary customers of Capital One, Bank of America, and JPMorgan Chase gave their banks higher marks.That was the starting point for our webinar with CUInsight on October 28, where Ron Shevlin, Managing Director and Chief Research Officer at Cornerstone Advisors, joined Bloom Credit CEO Christian Widhalm to walk through new research on a different way to think about the problem.

The research is called Monetize the Mission, and its central claim is uncomfortable. The industry has spent years investing in financial health, financial wellness, and financial literacy programs that do not produce the results anyone intended. Not because institutions lack commitment, but because the strategy itself is aimed at the wrong target.

Here is what the two of them covered:

The term itself is the first problem

Shevlin has been writing research in this space for close to three decades, and he opened with a complaint about vocabulary.
Financial health, he argued, is too soft a term to act on. There is no shared definition. Two institutions can both claim to improve it and mean entirely different things. A measure nobody agrees on is a measure nobody can be held to.

The second problem is the assumption underneath most programs: that teaching someone about money changes what they do with it. Shevlin tested that with an example from his own life. He knows nothing about the mechanical engineering inside his car. He drives it every day without difficulty. Low literacy, fine behavior.
Widhalm put a sharper point on it. Programs driven mostly by education, he said, move a fraction of a percent of actual financial behavior. People attend the seminar, read the material, and then go back to doing what they were already doing.

Shevlin also noted where these programs tend to aim. Education and literacy curricula are generally designed for people in real distress. That leaves out everyone in the middle, who may not be in crisis but still want to be in a better position than they are.

From health to performance

The replacement Shevlin proposes is performance, and the argument for it is almost obvious once stated.
Ask anyone who works at a financial institution about their own performance and the answer comes easily. Return on assets. Return on equity. Net interest margin. Loan growth. The industry has a hundred ways to measure itself.

Ask the same person to name one measure of their account holder’s financial performance and the answer usually stops.

So what should that measure be? Shevlin and his team considered building a new consumer score, then abandoned the idea. A single score only works if both providers and consumers adopt it, which rarely happens. What they landed on instead was simpler. People want two things: to make more money and to save more money.

The measurement system they built around those two outcomes is called financial lift. Financial lift is a way to measure how much a financial institution improves an account holder’s finances, in dollars saved or earned.The name is deliberate. Shevlin described it in aerodynamic terms. A heavy aircraft needs more power to leave the ground. So does a strained financial life. A lighter aircraft needs less, which describes the account holder who is already doing well and would still like to do better. The framework is designed to apply to everyone rather than to one segment.

The categories are concrete. Credit lift, where a stronger credit profile lowers the rate on the next loan. Interest lift, where the account holder pays less. Fee lift, where fees come down. Idle cash lift, where money sitting still earns more.

Every category but one converts directly to dollars, which is the part that matters. Cancel a subscription and that is lift. Negotiate a bill down and that is lift. Move savings from a 0.4% account to a 4.0% account and that is lift, in a number you can put in front of someone.

The gap between showing and improving

This is where the conversation turned to credit, and to a gap both speakers kept returning to.

Most institutions now show account holders their credit score. Far fewer help them change it. Widhalm explained why the two are not the same job. Displaying a score is a data problem, solved years ago. Influencing one is a furnishment problem, and until recently an institution had no practical way to solve it inside its own walls.

So account holders went looking elsewhere. Direct-to-consumer programs let people report rent and Telecom payments on their own, which helped those consumers and cut their institution out of the relationship entirely. Widhalm called it a loss of sovereignty over your own account holder.

What changed is that the same reporting can now happen through the checking account the account holder already uses. No new provider. No new payment behavior. Widhalm made the case that this is the only kind of intervention that reliably works, because it asks nothing of the person beyond a short enrollment.

The payments are already happening every month. They have simply never counted for anything.

And the engagement effects are measurable. Bloom Credit’s own data on enrolled account holders shows a 31% increase in bill payment activity, from 16.9 to 22.1 payments a month, and 13% deposit balance growth. Within 90 days of enrollment, 61% take out a new loan. One-year retention runs above 98%.

The pattern behind those numbers is worth understanding. When someone enrolls and notices that a bill paid from another account is not being reported, they move the payment over. More payments through the account means more activity, more deposits, and a relationship that is harder to leave.

The case to the CFO

Both speakers spent real time on the finance objection, which is the one that kills these projects.

Shevlin walked through the scenario modeled in the report: a single-product member, an auto loan, and an institution that refinances at a lower rate once the member’s credit profile improves. In the worst case, profitability on that member arrives in year three. He said reviewers pushed him to soften that and he declined, because the worst case is the number worth publishing.

His stronger argument is about where the money comes from. The smartest CFOs he talks to treat this as a displacement of marketing spend rather than a new cost line. Instead of buying brand advertising about great service and low rates, which has little measurable effect, they put the same dollars into products that engage account holders directly. One is an expense with no attribution. The other changes what the institution can credibly claim.

Widhalm added the acquisition math. Cost to acquire is roughly fixed. What varies is what you are offering when you get there, and whether that offer gives someone a reason to move more of their financial life to you.

Shevlin closed the topic with a distinction worth keeping. An institution can treat this as an initiative or as a strategy. Treated as an initiative, every partnership gets its own ROI calculation and most of them fail it. Treated as a strategy, the question changes to what the deepened relationship is worth over time.

What the audience asked

The questions asked at the end of the live event were as useful as the presentation.

On ‘one-and-done’ programs. One attendee described the familiar pattern: a member sits through a financial education session, gets handed a paper budget, and is never followed up with. Shevlin agreed and said the missing piece is not better-trained staff but products that keep working after the session ends. Financial coaching is valuable, he added, though it is delivered one-on-one by a human, and many people are not comfortable discussing their finances with anyone, including their own family. Tools reach more people and ask less of them.

On pairing education with action. Another asked how to combine education that earns trust with outcomes an account holder can see. Both speakers said the sequence runs the other way around. Lead with the measurable outcome, then let education supply context for it. Shevlin was direct about this in his closing: education, literacy and wellness are all worth doing, and they belong underneath a performance strategy rather than standing in for one.

Where this leaves institutions

Widhalm’s closing came back to the webinar’s title. Monetizing the mission is not a contradiction. Every credit union and community bank he talks to genuinely wants the best for its account holders. The failure is in treating that commitment as a cost center, which turns a potential lifelong relationship into a box to check.

The urgency is in who is opening accounts now. According to Cornerstone Advisors research, Gen Z and millennials opened 67% of new checking accounts last year, and SoFi alone opened more than the entire credit union industry combined. In a Cornerstone survey of 2,000 Gen Z and millennial consumers with no credit score or a score under 700, the top thing they wanted from a checking account was the ability to build credit from their transactions.

The account holders opening new checking accounts today are the prime borrowers of the next decade. Reaching them later, once they are 40 and already established, costs far more and meets far more resistance.

Shevlin’s version was about priority rather than rejection. Nothing in the research argues against financial education. The argument is that education without a performance strategy underneath it has no context, and context is what makes it stick.

Read the research. Monetize the Mission is available now, including the full financial lift framework and the ROI model behind it. Download the report.

Watch the replay. The full conversation is available on demand.

Grow Smarter

Enhance your member or customer experience, improve credit outcomes, and expand your reach through more intelligent consumer credit data.

Let’s Talk Join Newsletter